There I was, a solid 15 percent into If You Lie by Caleb Stephens, doing my usual post-dinner reading ritual (which involves dramatically flopping onto the couch like a Victorian woman with the vapors). And I’ll be honest—I was kind of bored. Not bad bored, just the kind of bored that happens when a story is still setting the stage, introducing all the characters, and making sure you know who’s who and what’s what. And before you say it, yes, Karen, I understand this is an essential part of storytelling. Doesn’t mean I have to like it.
So, I had my bookmark locked and loaded, ready to do literally anything else, when suddenly—BAM—the book sucker-punched me with action. And just like that, my plans to be a productive member of society were out the window. The rest of my night? Gone. Did I finish the book in one sitting? You bet I did. Do I regret it? Absolutely not.
The Art of the Slow Burn (and Why I Need to Chill)
Let’s talk about what If You Lie does right. First of all, Caleb Stephens knows how to keep you on your toes. The slow build-up I was mentally side-eyeing? Turns out, it was the perfect setup for the chaos that follows. It’s like being lulled into a false sense of security before the floor disappears beneath you. One minute you’re thinking, “Okay, I kind of know where this is going,” and the next, you’re clutching your Kindle like it just insulted your mother.
The tension? Chef’s kiss. The twists? Let’s just say I had to pause a couple of times to process what just happened. There’s this creeping sense of dread throughout the book that starts as a whisper and ends up screaming in your face. And while I won’t spoil anything, let’s just say that if you’re a fan of psychological thrillers that make you question everything, this one delivers.
The Twist (And My Moment of Glory)
Now, let’s address the big moment—the twist. I figured it out. Yup, you heard me. I had my detective hat on, and somewhere along the way, I cracked the case. But here’s the thing: it didn’t ruin the book for me at all. Instead of a disappointed, “Oh… I already knew that,” it was more of a victory dance situation. I had one of those AH HA! I knew it! I knew it! I knew it! moments that had me feeling like a genius detective. There’s something so satisfying about piecing things together and being right—but not in a way that makes the book feel predictable or cheap.
Article Continued Below
Even if you do figure it out, the execution is what makes it worthwhile. The writing keeps you engaged, the psychological tension never lets up, and even knowing where it was heading didn’t take away from the impact. In fact, I almost think it made it better because I got to revel in my smugness while still enjoying the ride.
The Pros and Cons (Because No Book Is Perfect, Well… Almost No Book)
Of course, no book is without its flaws (well… except maybe the 4MK series). The beginning was a bit slow for me, but in hindsight, I get why. Some people love a slow burn, and some people (me) get impatient and start tapping the screen like they’re fast-forwarding through commercials. But once the story found its footing, it sprinted.
Another thing worth mentioning is that while the twist worked for me, I could see how some readers might feel a little let down if they’re expecting something completely out of left field. It’s one of those twists where, if you’re paying attention, you can probably figure it out—but that doesn’t necessarily make it less enjoyable.
Final Thoughts: Should You Read If You Lie?
Absolutely. If you like thrillers that pull you in and refuse to let go, If You Lie is worth your time. It’s a book that rewards patience, and once it gets going, it doesn’t let up. Just maybe don’t start it late at night unless you’re okay with sacrificing sleep. (And possibly your peace of mind.)
It’s got suspense, it’s got intrigue, and it’s got that perfect mix of “Wait, what?” and “Oh my god, I knew it!” that makes for a great psychological thriller. So if you’re in the mood for a book that will have you second-guessing everything, give this one a shot.
If you still need to grab your copy of this great title, you can get it here on Amazon. Or get it for free when you sign up for a free trial from Audible.
Until next time, bookish besties—keep it brash, keep it bookish, and keep it true to you!
